Every Thursday, Nathan over at Fantasy Review Barn hosts a weekly party where blogs set out with Diana Wynne Jones’ hilarious book The Tough Guide to Fantasyland: The Essential Guide to Fantasy Travel in hand to explore all the tropes from their favorite stories. So sit back and enjoy the fun.

23rd April, 2015 – THE ACE

Some people are just ridiculously good at everything. Be it magic, swordplay, or all of the above. THE ACE has no equal.

Well, I’m going to interpret this topic as being about Mary Sue or Marty Stu characters. I might be wrong about that, but my “Aces” are going to focus on those types of characters.


jORGWhile I was awestruck by Prince of Thorns, I began to feel that Jorg was turning into a bit of an Ace, or Gary Stu, characters by the time I finished reading King of Thorns. While I know lots of people don’t agree with my dislike of this ever more powerful direction with Jorg, I think we can all, at least, agree that this guy is definitely an “Ace.”

In Prince, our favorite Ancrath is fourteen years old, but already a great swordsman, amazing tactician, and ruthless leader of a group of bandits. Later in the story, he shows an mindnumbing grasp of ancient history and ancient language (which he uses to decipher maps and texts that no one else ever has) as well as basically being better, smarter, and craftier than anyone he meets.

By the end of book two, Jorg has added to his amazing skills the power of necromancy. A skill that he appears to be stunningly proficient with little or no training in its use. Plus, Jorg is still more clever than anyone else alive in the world — as far as I could tell anyway.

Like I said, I’m not trying to hate one of my all-time favorite bad guys (Jorg is a bad guy in my eyes.), but he is definitely an “Ace” who seems to just be blessed with greater ability in everything than all his contemporaries.

Buy Prince of Thorns (The Broken Empire) at Amazon.

bloodandiron Now, I really hate to pick on this next guy, but even though his character morphs into less of an “Ace” or “Gary Stu” in the second book of the series, Horace was WAY good at everything at the start of this series.

It all starts off innocent enough in Blood and Iron. Horace beginning the story as a peasant nobody on the way to a Great Crusade before a storm shipwrecks him in enemy lands. This twist of fate results in him being captured and enslaved by his enemies. But before you know it, our dear Horace is discovered to be the most powerful sorcerer seen in the Akeshian Empire in generations! Not only that, he also turns out to be such a sexy man that every woman (including the ruling queen) can’t wait to get their hands on him!

Yeah, it was good to be Horace in book one. Well, at least, after the whole slavery thing, anyway. So for these reasons, Horace has got to be one of my top Aces.

Buy Blood and Iron (The Book of the Black Earth 1) at Amazon.



Not wanting to only hate on male Aces, I thought it was about time to list my first female Ace, and I couldn’t think of a better one than Amaranthe.

Now, before I say any more, I want to go ahead and acknowledge that some reviewers believe Buroker deliberately made Amaranthe a “Mary Sue” character to imbue the series with a “campy” feel, and since I haven’t spoken to the author, I don’t know if that interpretation is true or not. What I can say is that Amaranthe fits our “The Ace” topic extremely well.

In The Emperor’s Edge, Amaranthe begins as a police woman who is stuck in a dead end job with no hope of advancement. Soon, however, she turns into a woman who steals the heart of an emperor with a glance, wins the devotion of the most vicious assassin in the empire, outwits master politicians, outthinks foreign spies, and even outlasts a biological weapon unloaded on her. (No, I’m not exaggerating with that last statement.) Added to all this, our dear Amaranthe is the purest of hearts who wins the vilest of people over to her due to her nature. It is good to be Amaranthe in The Emperor’s Edge.

For these and many more reasons (Sorry, I’ve forgotten everything else Amaranthe is great at.) this lady has to be on my Aces list.

Buy The Emperor’s Edge Collection (Books 1, 2, and 3) at Amazon.


eragon Honestly, I hate to even put Eragon on the list, because I know Paolini was a teenager when he wrote this and that is probably why the title character is such an absolute Ace. I mean, the whole book reads very much like a teen’s wish fulfillment fantasy, after all. No matter my misgivings, however, Eragon has to be here.

As the story begins, Eragon isn’t anything special; he is just a simple farm boy. Soon, though, his transformation into a total Ace begins. First, he turns into a master swordsman seemingly overnight. (I know he practices for a few weeks, but he is a master in that short a time?) Second, he goes from illiterate to literate in record time then begins to learn the ancient language of magic, which he is brilliant at. Magic? Not a big problem. Everything seems to come easy for this youth once he leaves home. I’m sure he wished he had fled sooner.

You really can’t be much more of an Ace than Eragon.

Buy Eragon (Inheritance, Book 1) at Amazon.


DRIZZT I’m not what you would label a Drizzt fanboy. Sure, I really enjoyed the Icewind Dale trilogy when it was initially released years ago, and, yes, I’ve found the Companions Codex a fun, entertaining read, but I’m not so attached that I can’t see the inherent flaws in this famous drow. The main one being he is an Ace — especially when it comes to his battle prowess.

As anyone who has read Drizzt knows, the guy is the best swordsman ever. At least, it seems so. Over the years (and his many books) he has also accumulated an assortment of magical items that have given him numerous skills; skills that have made him nearly a one man army. Well, maybe, he isn’t a one man army, but you get my point, the guy is a bit overpowered at times.

Like I said, I really enjoy Drizzt’s adventures, but at times, I wish he was not such an Ace. A little frailty would make him an even better character, in my opinion.

Buy The Crystal Shard: The Legend of Drizzt, Book IV at Amazon.


MISTBORN EU Some people might find this Ace pick a bit perplexing, since Kelsier isn’t the most powerful person in the book. I mean, the Steel Inquisitors and the Lord Ruler are way overpowered compared to Kelsier. But I’m putting him on this list not for his overpowered allomancy skills but because of his other skills: his cleverness and cunning.

Without going into the ending of the novel, I will just say that something happens which takes an enormous amount of deviousness, planning and manipulation of not just a few people but multitudes. The scope of it is nearly mind boggling. In my opinion, the ability of one person to accomplish it is beyond belief. And for Kelsier to be able to pull this event off was a bit deus ex machine, turning him into an overpowered character in my opinion.

But that is just my opinion.

Buy Mistborn: The Final Empire at Amazon.


FEMALE ASSASSIN I know this one is very broad, but I’m just very tired of every assassin in fantasy literature being an Ace. Whether it’s Royce in The Riyrian Revelations or Kylar Stern of Night Angel or whomever, these never ending parade of assassins seem very overpowered to the point of being more superheroes with super powers than true flesh and blood people trained to kill.

This entry was posted in Fantasy, Graphic Novels, Lists, Tough Traveling and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.


  1. The assassin comment made me think of the origins of the word. As I was saying in a recent post, you may be forgiven for never having heard of the old man in the mountain (no, not the Unabomber), but he led one of the most feared Islamic cults of Medieval times: the Hashishin sect. Even Saladin and the Crusaders feared him.

    You see, when the old man wanted to get rid of an opponent, his men would find the perfect patsy, drug him and take him to their mountain sanctuary. This palace was designed to resemble paradise, with lush gardens filled with exotic trees and wild – yet docile – animals. Beautiful girls played the lute in every room, their sweet voices singing joyous songs. There were all the gorgeous women the poor soul could enjoy. Copious amounts of wine and hash enhanced the experience. Delicious food spilled over from every table (presumably, most of it sweets).

    After a few heavenly days, the kidnapped man would be drugged again and taken back to his village and his dreary dreg of an existence. Upon waking up, he was told he had experienced a glimpse of heaven; a heaven that he could enjoy for all eternity, if only he did a small deed for the old man. He need not fear death, for even if he failed, he would still be a martyr and go to heaven.

    Needless to say, few failed to meet their goal, and thus the term assassin (Hashishin) was born.


  2. As for the actual comment on Aces, I agree with you. Personally, I love heroes that are fallible, just like I prefer my antiheroes to have redeeming features. But I know a lot of people who want things as black and white as possible. Indeed, a reviewer recently gave my book three stars because, “it took too long for the bad guys to get what was coming to them” 🙂


  3. You’re right, Jorg is totally ridiculous! He made my list too, as did Kylar from Night Angel. Drizzt is also a great pick, and I wish I’d thought of Eragon too (definitely teenage wish-fulfilment through and through!)


  4. The over-the-top “awesomeness” of Horace, in Blood and Iron, was one of the reasons I could not finish the book: it’s a pity, because the premise looked more than solid…


  5. lynnsbooks says:

    Haha – I love your ‘assassins’ choice. That’s too good and you’re quite right! And Kelsier, I like that choice because he might not be the most powerful but he does have a plan, and you have to love a man with a plan. 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Kaja says:

    I’ve been thinking about reading Lawrence’s books but he’s been getting so much bad publicity lately :/ This Jorg character doesn’t really make me want to read them, either!
    Ah, Eragon is an excellent choice. I completely missed him though I see the entire series on my shelf every day, sigh. And you’re right, wish fulfillment fantasy is a great description!
    I’m not surprised we both included Kelsier this week! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  7. mervih says:

    I can’t believe I forgot Drizzt! Great choices.


  8. rudejasper says:

    I haven’t read the Mark Lawrence series but I’m already rolling my eyes with leading a gang of bandits at 14. And, I’m totally with you on Kelsier!

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Haha, Jorg is certainly an “Ace” at being a terrible person. Mastered at the tender age of 13.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Stabs says:

    One of my favourite Aces is Garet Jax from the Wishsong of Shannara.

    Now he’s introduced in a standard trope – lone stranger passes a gang of ruffians, words are exchanged, etc, then he turns out to be some super warrior and kicks all their butts. However there’s a delightful twist – as he turns to the last member of the gang and says “what about you?” the villain shakes his head and says “I know who you are.” There you have it – a warrior no one would fight unless they failed to recognise him.

    That continues through the story, a sense of everyone in the world seeing him as a superstar. Just as in our world no one in their right mind would throw a punch at Mike Tyson.


  11. Dave says:

    Tavore Paran in the Malazan series. He spends so many books building up a fascinating universe, and then has this character with no personality just march through it unscathed conquering all before her despite all internal logic in the series. Absolutely ruined the last 2 books for me.


  12. Zoe says:

    I’m surprised that the legendary warrior Purthin Khlaylock and ordained Knight of Khryl from the Acts of Caine series hasn’t been mentioned anywhere.


  13. You are so right about assassins! They’re kind of overpoweringly good at everything by necessity, I guess. But still, it would be nice to see one who’s a bit more realistic. Good call with Kelsier as well – he’s got the legend surrounding his escape from enslavement that makes him even more of an Ace, since everyone’s in awe of him.


  14. Pingback: BEST OF FANTASY |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s