TOP 5 WEDNESDAY: Books I Feel Differently About Now


Today, the guys in the Goodreads Top 5 Wednesday group had a great topic: Books You Feel Differently About Now!   This can be books that you feel differently about after you’ve re-read them or just had more time to think about them.  It can be books you gave a low rating to initial but now appreciate more, or a story you loved when you first read it, but now see many problems with it.

Obviously, this topic is a fairly broad one, and so I narrowed it down by deciding to focus on books I read for the first time in the last five years.  No need to go back any further than that, since we all know our opinions about books from our younger years will definitely have changed quite a lot.  So, let’s get to it!

dragon hunters5. DRAGON HUNTERS

After having loved When the Heavens Fall, I had really high expectations for book two.  Maybe, too high.  And when Dragon Hunters focused on another section of the world with all new characters and a different type of plot, I was not quite as infatuated with it.  Thankfully, Marc Turner gave me an opportunity to beta read Red Tide, the third installment of the series, and it brought into focus the trajectory of this epic, causing most of my gripes about Dragon Hunters to evaporate.


half a king4. HALF A KING

I was hard on this book after I read it.  Christened it GRIMWHINE!  And while I stand by much of my criticism, I realize now most of my angst was due to unreasonable expectations for Half a King.  The Joe Abercrombie hype I’d been hearing setting this novel up as to be a big letdown.  But after several years of contemplation, I realize this initial volume in the Shattered Sea series is a good fantasy.  Not great, but definitely good.  Maybe a little whiny at times, but still good.  Something I wouldn’t hesitate to tell others to give a try.  But don’t get me started on the next two books in the series, because it hasn’t been long enough yet.



As anyone who views my blog from time to time will probably know, I’m a big fan of the Seven Forges series by James A. Moore.  It is my favorite sword-and-sorcery series on the 21st Century.  So far, anyway.  But when I closed the book on its initial volume, I had real doubts this amazing world and its mesmerizing denizens would ever realize their full potential, because the book Seven Forges did have its problems.  Thankfully, Mr. Moore put it all together in the next three installments, taking me on a grand ride and making me appreciate the foundation he laid for it all in this novel.


king of thorns2. KING OF THORNS

I have to go ahead and admit that I really hated this book when I finished it.  Where Prince of Thorns had awed me with its gritty, bloody brutality and its brilliant but insane main character, King made me cringe in nearly ever way.  Thank God, I eventually broke down, read Emperor of Thorns, and understood what Mark Lawrence was doing the whole time.  All of which is my long winded way of saying I actually like King of Thorns now.  Don’t know why that was so hard to type.  🙂


beyond redemption1. BEYOND REDEMPTION

I really liked this novel when I experienced it.  Grimdark debauchery and brutality, madness and mayhem at its finest. But I didn’t fully appreciate Michael Fletcher’s amazing writing ability.  Now, having read even more of the grimdark genre, I stand in awe.  How Mr. Fletcher could created a world of madness (where those with the greatest insanity have the power to recreate the world around them) and craft a compelling story within that framework with characters readers despise yet still want to read about is utterly amazing.  For that reason, this book continues to rise within my mind, and I hope other grimdark lovers will discover its divine madness.


That is my top five.  What are yours?

This entry was posted in Top Five Wednesday and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to TOP 5 WEDNESDAY: Books I Feel Differently About Now

  1. Awesome list! Beyond Redemption is truly an amazing book that needs more recognition!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Some quality books and I second what MightyThorJRS says about Beyond Redemption.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Heh, I was the opposite with King of Thorns and Emperor of Thorns. I really enjoyed the second, but was let down by the last one. guess it turns out what Lawrence was doing with the series didn’t work so well for me. I still need to read both Seven Forges and Dragon Hunters. And yes, Beyond Redemption is incredibly well done!!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Now I wish I had continued with the series after Seven Forges. The book didn’t wow me, but from all the reviews I’ve seen, everyone says subsequent sequels got better and better.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. “Not great, but good”: sometimes this is all we ask from a book! And I’m glad you changed your opinion on “Half a King” because it’s a solid, involving story. And it’s true that a little time and distance makes us see things in a different perspective…

    Liked by 1 person

  6. @lynnsbooks says:

    Love your choices. I actually loved the entire Broken Empire series though I know some of the people I chat to had mixed reactions. Beyond Redemption is a book I’m hoping to get to this month. I’ve got very seriously behind and that is one of my catch up books which I’m really looking forward to.
    Grimwhine – very funny. I did like the first but I haven’t continued with the series for some reason.
    The 2nd Marc Turner is another book I’m hoping to get to this month.
    Lynn 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  7. PHS says:

    Reblogged this on Archer's Aim and commented:
    An interesting take on these books. I hope to get to them at some point. Reblogging on Archer’s Aim.


  8. Toni Betzner says:

    No, I have to agree the Broken Empire series and Half a King are just terrible. I don’t think i’ll ever feel differently though. I think the main problem with both are the MC’s. I’m so tired of the weak revenge plots against murdering uncles. Can we say overdone and boring? And the main characters are just so whiny and immature and overly brooding. And the side characters were bad, except Makin. I liked him.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s